Jump to content
John Robinson

atc-discussion PDC yes or no?

Recommended Posts

John Robinson

So I've been looking through various vMATS files and keep coming across PDC, I have seen on the VATSIM.net forum someone has created vSMR and there is another version I believe for acars? Does anyone use it on VATSIM UK? If so is it easy to set up?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Fraser Barnes

Using vSMR, yes it is very easy. You just need to register for an account, enter the password you are given when entering info and then log in. It's the lack of pilots who actually want to use PDC that is the problem but if you put in your remarks that you are using PDC, it might encourage others to try it out.

Edited by Fraser Barnes
typo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
John Robinson

Going to get it installed i think just to have a play see if anyone wants it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Zafar Ballard

The entire time I've switched it on in vSMR I've had one pilot use it. I'd definitely like to see it used more often!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
James Yuen

I personally don't use vSMR's PDC feature, however should a pilot request a PDC, I offer them this by PM:

.pdc .msg $aircraft $dep PDC: $aircraft CLRD TO $arr $deprwy via $sid INIT ALT: $alt squawk $asquawk ATIS $atiscode NO READBACK REQUIRED Contact $callsign on frequency $com when FULLY ready to push and start with stand number, ATIS info, aircraft type AND current QNH

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Fraser Cooper
2 hours ago, James Yuen said:

I personally don't use vSMR's PDC feature, however should a pilot request a PDC, I offer them this by PM:

.pdc .msg $aircraft $dep PDC: $aircraft CLRD TO $arr $deprwy via $sid INIT ALT: $alt squawk $asquawk ATIS $atiscode NO READBACK REQUIRED Contact $callsign on frequency $com when FULLY ready to push and start with stand number, ATIS info, aircraft type AND current QNH

I think the key word here is 'request'. PDC is requested by the crew and not sent to them instantly as they connect. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Joseph Messore
15 hours ago, Fraser Cooper said:

I think the key word here is 'request'. PDC is requested by the crew and not sent to them instantly as they connect. :)

Yeah. Always make sure the pilots "request" a PDC. I found that out the hard way.......:mellow:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Trevor Hannant

Until such time as it's integrated into aircraft itself and doesn't require yet another piece of software running on your desktop (i.e. sim, vpilot, VA ACARS software, mapping program...), it's usefulness and it's takeup will be limited.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Fraser Barnes
31 minutes ago, Trevor Hannant said:

Until such time as it's integrated into aircraft itself and doesn't require yet another piece of software running on your desktop (i.e. sim, vpilot, VA ACARS software, mapping program...), it's usefulness and it's takeup will be limited.  

I asked about PDC on another post and came to the conclusion that the only way PDC will become popular is if, like you said, add-ons can implement VATSIM connections in their own systems. One to look out for is FSLabs, who as far as I'm aware, have the AOC system setup in their FMGS and you can access certain features like getting your VATSIM flightplan from the server and loading it in the aircraft. If VATSIM and FSLabs maybe team up together and try and create some sort of ACARS system for VATSIM, then I think PDC would takeoff (no pun intended).

It's just how much work would require is the question and whether other developers would do the same. But for now I'll try and use the Hoppie ACARS and put it in my remarks which might encourage controllers to maybe use it as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Matthew Piper
3 hours ago, Trevor Hannant said:

Until such time as it's integrated into aircraft itself and doesn't require yet another piece of software running on your desktop (i.e. sim, vpilot, VA ACARS software, mapping program...), it's usefulness and it's takeup will be limited.  

However, the PDC can be sent through the vatsim standard text channel. I was flying out of Heathrow recently, and there was only London Control online, I called him up and he said that a PDC was being issued. I can only imagine this is so he can free up the mic time for more important transmissions. Therefore, I can see a use of PDCs in busier times to help the controllers who are covering multiple positions.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Connor Faulder

I've only ever once put "PDC Available" in my controller ATIS on Heathrow Ground and had 3 pilots request it via CPDLC and 2 via text. I guess that shows the demand can be there.

 

I've requested PDC once or twice when flying but mainly use the hoppie client/Project A330 client for enroute CPDLC if the European controllers are offering it.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Fraser Barnes
45 minutes ago, Connor Faulder said:

CPDLC if the European controllers are offering it

CPLDC seems to be quite popular with Eurocontrol, Langen, Bremen etc. so maybe there should be a bit more promotion of CPLDC in the London Area so that some pilots can have CPLDC in both Eurocontrol and London. The more controller use it, the more pilots will use it and vice versa.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Johan Grauers

All of this is depending on what Trevor said

 

18 hours ago, Trevor Hannant said:

Until such time as it's integrated into aircraft itself and doesn't require yet another piece of software running on your desktop (i.e. sim, vpilot, VA ACARS software, mapping program...), it's usefulness and it's takeup will be limited.  

 

Until PDC/CPDLC/Datalink and so on is integrated in an easy to use way so it reduces workload, rather than increase, the uptake will be small.

The real PDC system we work with is either completely automatic (most of the time) or semi-automatic when we set it to be. It takes me probably no more than 3 or 4 seconds to send a semi-automatic PDC, it takes me no effort at all when in automatic. Last I looked at the systems on offer for vatsim (granted, it is a while ago now) they took longer to use than voice clearance at first, and even when proficent required several inputs to produce and send the message.

 

It needs to be integrated properly into the controller client and into the aircraft in order to be used, if that happens it could be an extremely good system for vatsim. However until that day I think you will only get a limited uptake.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
John Robinson

I do believe there is a euroscope plugin I think the issue is primarily the aircraft 'manufactuers' not offering an aircraft plugin. It is a shame as it would make controlling as stated easier and ultimately more realistic.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Fraser Barnes

There is a Euroscope plugin: vSMR and there is a pilot client: Hoppie's ACARS but they just take a while to setup and run outside of the sim.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Anthony Gardner

And as a controller with no knowledge of either PDC or Hoppie's, how do I deal if a pilot requests a PDC? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Connor Faulder

"Unable" 

 

If someone is requesting PDC at Liverpool then they're certainly being creative :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Anthony Gardner

Thanks Connor.  This is something that I do not need to concern myself with at the moment. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Andreas Fuchs

Hi there,

"ze Germans" will be holding their first CPDLC Topic Night this Friday! Why don't you just pop in and try PDC and CPDLC?

The installation of CPDLC software is not that complicated, especially when using the CPDLC Quick Starter Manual: https://forums.vatsim.net/viewtopic.php?f=7&t=69970

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • Maher Abaza
      By Maher Abaza
      Hello all,
      I was accepted yesterday to control in the UK under VG5. The email said I could control anywhere specified in that area without the need for any sessions of familiarization.
      I really think I should be getting at least an introductory session for controlling in the UK. I hope I can find some available members of this community (C1 controllers, not necessarily mentors or INS rated) to help me get in the groove rather than embarrass myself and annoy pilots on London West Control 🙂
      Help appreciated,
      Maher
    • Amedeo Fasano
      By Amedeo Fasano
      Hello,
      i have just started using VATSIM.
      In the real aviation life I fly from Oxford (EGTK) and have an instrument rating. I intend to use VATSIM to initially simulate IFR flights from and to Oxford using other IFR airports in UK and France as destinations. Oxford is in class G and my destination airports might or might not be in class D (but they will be IFR aerodromes). I might also fly in CAS only during portions of the flight. For example flying from Oxford to Newquay at FL100 (I fly an SR22) will have both aerodromes with instrument procedures available but located in class G and will contain only a portion of the flight being in class A and in airways and/or over class D CTRs which I will need clearance to transit. I will of course file a flight plan. This is a typical mission in my real aviation life. The questions I have are the following ones:
      1) will I be able to talk to Oxford and Newquay for IFR , departure and arrival clearances and control even if in the controllers on line list I do not see controllers active in these airports? I am referring in particular to the TWR and APP frequencies which are fundamentally important on departures and arrivals. Yesterday I  saw that there were controllers in Manchester and was able to talk to them. Then I repositioned myself in Oxford and I was not able to talk to a controller (there was no controller indicated as active in Oxford).
      2) would the answer to question 1 be different if I was departing and/or arriving from/into airports in class D?  Is there always a controller available in class D airports?
      3) do I need to see a controller active for London control in order to be cleared to enter controlled airspace and obtain radar control service?
      4) what will happen during the portions of the flight when I will be outside CAS? In the real life normally I would be handed over to a LARS controller who will give me traffic service or even deconfliction service if I ask for it, being on an IFR FPL. I might also move from a class A airspace over to a Class D airspace if there is a class D CTR on route (for example Cardiff or Bristol in the above mentioned example). How will the handover from London control to the respective en route clad D airspace work? Can I assume that there will be controller available for the class D zones to give clearance and control (either radar or procedural control)?
      in a nutsheel my questions are about controllers availability to control IFR flights in the UK airspace. In the real life they are there from beginning to end (including London Information if there is no other ATCU available). What about in the VATSIM world? Or in VATSIM I am supposed to first check what controllers are available and then define my flight plan according to controllers’ availability?
      i attach a PDF with the flight plan for the EGTK-EGHQ flight in the example
      Apologies for the long question. I tried to be as clear as I could be.
      Help appreciated. Thanks in advance.
      FlightLog EGTK-EGHQ 190225 1130.pdf
    • Magnus Meese
      By Magnus Meese
      I’ve been zipping around the country VFR the last few days exploring FTX England, and have assumed Radio-airports are not serviced on the network. Relevant CTR has been online during some of my flights, and I’ve communicated appropriately for TWR &AFIS fields, but remained on unicom without complain for all the AGs. Then yesterday I had a thought to look up the rule for this, and while I found none, some posts describe S2s manning AG-positions. 
      The question then becomes, does top down apply here, or would APP and CTR prefer not to be having to pay attention to one guy reporting in and out of such aerodromes during their hours of service?
    • Louie Lister
      By Louie Lister
      Hi All,
      I've just logged onto Heathrow for the first time in a while. My adjacent controllers are telling me they're being told that GMC now does the stand allocation. I've always been under the impression that GMP has always had the role of stand allocation, it's always what I was taught and have taught. 
      This is apparently coming from ATC staff/LL Mentors that this is a Heathrow specific. However, in the vMATS and Moodle, it mentions that GMP has this role at Heathrow. We have a Heathrow event coming up next month, so could someone help clear this up beforehand to save confusion amongst the GMC & GMP controllers to guarantee a smooth running event. 
      Thanks in advance,
      Louie
       
    • Lewis Hammett
      By Lewis Hammett
      Dear all,
      There is a P1 exam this Sunday evening 10th Feb; the candidate would appreciate some ATC to help make the exam a success.
      Please can we ask for ATC cover from EGCC, LONDON & EGKK; beginning from 18:30Z (EGCC).
      Many thanks,
      Lewis
×
×
  • Create New...